Our experienced Columbia criminal defense lawyers at Shealey Law Firm explain the South Carolina grand jury process. Hereās what to know if youāre facing an indictment.
What Is a Grand Jury and What Does It Do in South Carolina?
A grand jury is a panel of citizens chosen for jury duty in South Carolina. Grand jurors hear evidence and decide whether someone should face criminal charges.
After hearing the evidence, jury members vote on whether to approve criminal charges against the person who is the subject of the proceedings. If they vote in favor of charges, an indictment will be issued, and criminal proceedings will commence.
How Does a Grand Jury Differ from a Trial Jury?
The grand jury decides whether criminal charges should be filed. They donāt decide whether the person is guilty of the offense. If the grand jury votes in favor of the indictment, it only starts criminal charges.
Trial jurors hear a formal trial in an open courtroom. They decide guilt or innocence.
Differences Between Grand Jury and Trial Jury in SC
| Grand Jury | Trial Jury | |
| How many jurors | 18, plus alternates | 12, plus alternates |
| Do rules of evidence apply? | No (See Rule 1101). | Yes |
| Are the proceedings held in open court? | No | Yes |
| Is there a judge? | No | Yes |
| Is a unanimous decision required? | No | Yes |
| Does the defendant have the right to a lawyer? | No | Yes |
| Can the defense present evidence? | No | Yes |
| Does the jury vote in secret? | Yes | Yes |
| What is the legal standard? | Probable cause | Guilt or innocence |
How Are Grand Jurors Selected in South Carolina?
Each county in South Carolina has its own grand jury system. Thereās also a statewide grand jury.
The state grand jury selection process starts with 700 people chosen at random. There is no fixed number for county grand juries. Each clerk may decide how many people to summon.
The court may inquire about the qualifications of each person to serve. Jurors must be U.S. citizens. They must be at least 18 years old. Felony convictions are disqualifying. The court may excuse people for hardships like medical issues and dependent care.
Note: If youāre on the grand jury, you canāt also be on the trial jury.
What Evidence Can Be Presented to a Grand Jury?
A SC grand jury may consider:
- Witness statements
- Physical exhibits, documents
- Search warrants
- Subpoenas for records, like financial records, emails, and digital information
- Wiretaps, with judge approval required
The rules of evidence donāt apply. That means hearsay can be admitted, even if it would not be admissible at trial.
What Happens After a Grand Jury Returns an Indictment?
When the grand jury returns an indictment, the indictment is filed with the court. The defendant may be arrested. The court will ask the defendant to enter a plea. The court will address bond and conditions of release.
The case will then proceed through the criminal justice process. Preliminary proceedings may include court motions and settlement negotiations.
Note: There is no defense right to a preliminary hearing if there is a grand jury indictment.
Can a Grand Jury Refuse to Indict? (What a ‘No True Bill’ Means)
Yes. The grand jury votes on an indictment. If they vote yes, itās a true bill. If they vote no, itās a no bill. If they vote no bill, the case is dismissed.
The county solicitor may bring the case to the grand jury again later.
SC State Grand Jury: How It Differs from a Regular Grand Jury
The state grand jury handles certain cases that have statewide interest. Examples are:
- Human trafficking
- Public corruption
- Criminal gang activity
- Money laundering
- Election irregularities
- Environmental issues
- Computer and internet crimes
- Narcotics, dangerous drugs, controlled substances
- Obscenity
- Terrorism
- Financial fraud
S.C. Code Title 14, Chapter 7, Article 15 is the State Grand Jury Act.
Grand Juries and Trial Juries ā The Differences
Grand jury proceedings are non-adversarial. Not only does the defendant lack the right to present a defense, but they also donāt have the right to know that the proceedings are underway. And the grand jury doesnāt have to be unanimous for criminal charges. The proceeding focuses on probable cause, not the higher burden of proof beyond a reasonable doubt required to convict of criminal charges.
Do You Have Rights Before a Grand Jury in South Carolina?
Yes. You have important rights before a grand jury in South Carolina. Generally, you must appear. However, you can plead your Fifth Amendment right to avoid self-incrimination. Generally, you must invoke your Fifth Amendment rights question by question.
It can be complicated. The grand jury can offer something called use immunity. With use immunity, you must answer, but prosecutors canāt use your statements against you. Use immunity doesnāt apply to perjury.
You canāt have your attorney in the room. But they can be outside, and you can consult with them during proceedings.
What to Do If You’ve Been Indicted in Columbia, SC
If youāve been indicted in Columbia, SC, or even hear that grand jury proceedings are underway, contact a lawyer. The sooner you involve an attorney, the sooner they can help you fight the charges.
Donāt talk to the police. Politely ask for your attorney.
Shealey Law Firm represents people facing grand jury proceedings and indictments. Call or message us for immediate legal help.